MarketUnclouded Newsletter Follow YouTubeAccount
Options terms explained

Does selling weekly options work?

Iron condors, credit spreads and iron flies win most of the time, which makes them feel safe. We tested them on 30 stocks and ETFs every week from March 2022 to November 2026 with real bid and ask prices. Here is what happened.

Selling options has a simple pitch: most options expire worthless, so the seller usually keeps the premium. Weekly options make that pitch even more tempting, because the clock runs out fast. We wanted to know whether it holds up once you trade at real prices, so we tested it.

How we tested it

  • 30 tickers: 10 ETFs (SPY, QQQ, IWM, DIA, GLD, TLT, XLF, XLE, SMH, EEM) and 20 large stocks (including NVDA, AAPL, TSLA, AMD, META, AMZN, MSFT and JPM).
  • Every week from March 2022 to November 2026: 7,029 ticker-weeks, through the 2022 bear market, the 2023โ€“25 rally and the April 2025 sell-off.
  • Real quotes: each trade was entered at the actual bid and ask between 3:30 and 3:59 pm ET on the last trading day of the week and held to the next weekly expiration. We assumed a fill halfway between the mid price and the bid/ask, plus $0.65 per contract.
  • Strikes from the expected move: short strikes at the edges of the at-the-money straddle, wings about 1% further out, the same rules as our Options Chain strategy guide.

What we found

Returns below are profit divided by the capital at risk (the worst-case loss), summed over all trades.

  • Iron condor at the expected move: won 67% of the time, but returned โˆ’7.3% of capital at risk, and lost money in every calendar year. Even at mid-price fills it was โˆ’5.0%.
  • Bear call credit spread: won 80% of the time, returned โˆ’4.7%, negative every year.
  • Bull put credit spread: won 83% of the time, returned โˆ’2.2%.
  • Iron fly: won 43%, returned โˆ’8.3%.
  • At-the-money butterfly: the weakest of all at โˆ’35%, mostly from paying the bid/ask spread on four legs.
  • Long straddle: +2.1%. Long call (0.60 delta): +6.3%, helped by a rising market in 2023โ€“25.

The high win rates are real. The problem is the size of the losses: the occasional week that runs through a short strike costs several weeks of collected premium, and the bid/ask spread takes a cut of every trade.

Why: weekly options were priced about right

Across all 7,029 weeks, the stock finished inside the expected move 58% of the time, and the average move was 1.02 times the expected move. That is almost exactly what the straddle prices in. Implied volatility on weekly at-the-money options averaged only about 1.3 volatility points above the volatility that followed, too thin a cushion to cover trading costs.

When selling did worst

  • When options looked cheap (implied volatility below 20-day realized volatility): the condor lost money in every year we tested.
  • In earnings weeks: the condor returned โˆ’9.1% and the iron fly โˆ’11.3%.
  • In a volatile market (SPY's 20-day realized volatility above 20%): iron flies and condors lost about 19%, while long calls and straddles did best. See market volatility regimes.

What this means for you

None of this says selling options can never work. Traders who sell premium well usually manage size carefully, avoid earnings, choose when to sell rather than selling every week, and get filled near the mid. It does say that a high win rate is not the same as an edge, and that the bid/ask spread matters more than most people think. Before you sell premium, look at the max loss, what the trade costs at the bid and ask, and whether an event is priced into the expiry.

One study is not a guarantee: these results cover one period and one set of rules, and past results do not predict future ones.

Common questions

Do iron condors make money?

In our backtest of 30 tickers from March 2022 to November 2026, weekly iron condors placed at the expected-move edges won 67% of the time but lost 7.3% of capital at risk after realistic costs, and were negative in every calendar year.

Why do high-win-rate option strategies lose money?

Because the losing weeks are much bigger than the winning ones. A credit spread might collect $100 most weeks and lose $700 in a week that runs through the short strike, and the bid/ask spread takes a cut of every trade.

Are weekly options overpriced?

Not by much. In our test the stock finished inside the straddle-based expected move 58% of the time and moved 1.02 times the expected move on average, which is close to fair pricing.

When did selling options do worst?

When implied volatility was below recent realized volatility, in earnings weeks, and when the market itself was volatile (SPY's 20-day realized volatility above 20%).

Educational content only, not investment advice. Options involve substantial risk and are not suitable for all investors.